Enjoy this content as part of Julia B. Fee Sotheby’s Inside The Community series.
Mamaroneck transcends the standard suburban narrative, presenting instead a storied maritime tapestry where the heritage of the Sound Shore converges with a distinctly cosmopolitan pulse. It is a sanctuary defined by the rhythmic tides of the harbor and the prestige of its sprawling estates, offering an atmosphere that is simultaneously historic and avant-garde.
Here are the places that tell the story of Mamaroneck:
Breakfast
619 Halstead Avenue, Mamaroneck
Consistently voted amongst the best delis in Westchester, Anthony’s is known all over the county for their breakfast and lunch sandwiches. The Breakfast Barge can feed an entire family on one wedge, with their bacon egg and cheese sandwich also highly touted. For lunch, try their signature sandwich, The Godfather, featuring every deli meat you can name. Anthony’s has been the go-to deli for anyone in Mamaroneck for almost 40 years. As they like to say themselves, “Give us a try, we guarantee you’ll be back.”
419 Mamaroneck Avenue, Mamaroneck
More of a sit-down spot, The Roaster Cafe is Mamaroneck’s newest early morning dining establishment. First opening serving strictly coffee, it has evolved into a true bistro with an expanded menu. Highlights on the menu include a multitude of pancake options, along with organic platters and egg sandwiches, all of which are served generously.
Lunchtime Stroll
316 Mamaroneck Avenue, Mamaroneck
The most famous location in Mamaroneck, Sal’s has been king of the sicilian slice since 1964. Voted best in Westchester every year, Sal’s is why you come to Mamaroneck. With a full kitchen in house as well, you can sit down and enjoy other staples such as the meatball wedge. The salad pizza also comes with high praise. Sal’s is known all over the world for their pizza, with the family recipe now centuries old. A true master at their craft, Sal’s is nothing short of a must-have.
123 Mamaroneck Avenue, Mamaroneck
After putting down one (or several) slices at Sal’s, take a walk down to Harbor Island Park, where you can be on the Long Island Sound with miles of views. Multiple baseball fields, playgrounds, tennis courts, and a public beach give an activity for everyone to do. During the summer, Stephen E. Johnston Beach hosts various group activities such as kayaking, yoga, day camp for children, and much more. There is fun for the whole family to be had at Harbor Island Park.
Shopping
335 Mamaroneck Avenue, Mamaroneck
Originating in Harlem in 1908, Miller’s Mamaroneck location has been cemented in local history since 1948. Miller’s is always stocked with toys for all ages, spanning from children’s books to complex board games for adults. They also carry a variety of bicycles and clothing items. Simply put, Miller’s has been, and always will be a one stop shop for children in Mamaroneck.
A true hidden gem, Siren is as fully stocked of a boutique store as they come. Ranging from hats to rings, scarves to custom matchboxes and candles, Siren truly is a place to get lost in. Modest prices keep customers coming back for all of their needs for every occasion. There is rarely something you cannot find at Siren.
Dinner & Drinks
211 Mamaroneck Avenue, Mamaroneck
Stepping it up a notch for dinner, Nonna Carola has quickly become a popular nighttime destination for those seeking a sophisticated Italian dinner. Generous portions would be an understatement, as their chicken scarpiello can feed multiple people with one order. Before sitting down for your meal, you can grab a drink at their fully stocked bar. Now featuring their new take out counter, Nonna Carola is establishing themselves as a force in Mamaroneck.
100 W Boston Post Road, Mamaroneck
The sister establishment to Jack’s in Eastchester, Jill’s is the newcomer to the Mamaroneck restaurant scene. Rooted in Irish heritage, Jill’s menu is diverse and full of dishes you never knew you would love. From their shepherd’s pie empanadas to their short rib mac and cheese, there is nothing simple about their dishes. With plenty of drink options as well, Jill’s is a great spot for a full meal or a quick hang with some friends.